************* CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY
*************
http://www.sw-center.org
ALERT #201 9-2-99
§ THE CENTER AND NEW WEST RESEARCH RELEASE TAXPAYER'S
GUIDE
TO SUBSIDIZED RANCHING IN THE SOUTHWEST
§ LAWSUIT FILED
TO SAVE RARE HAWAIIAN SPECIES
§ CENTER TO SUE TO PROTECT WHITE
ABALONE-SPECIES HAS
DECLINED BY 99.9% IN THIRTY YEARS
§ MEXICAN
WOLF REINTRODUCTION UPDATE
§ CENTER WINS FIRST ROUND IN SAN DIEGO SPECIES
PLAN LAWSUIT
_____________________
THE CENTER AND NEW WEST RESEARCH
RELEASE TAXPAYER'S GUIDE TO
SUBSIDIZED RANCHING IN THE SOUTHWEST
The
Center for Biological Diversity and New West Research
published a
comprehensive report which looks at the plethora
of tax breaks and subsidies
for public lands ranchers in
Arizona and New Mexico. This report documents
the existence
and impact of governmental support for grazing in the
arid
Southwest. The ranching industry could not survive without
the vast
array of tax benefits and subsidies hundreds of
millions of dollars per year
that result from its
disproportionate influence. Particularly egregious,
public
lands ranching is the most ubiquitous form of land
degradation in
the region. More than 60 million acres of
federal and state public lands are
currently grazed by
cattle in Arizona and New Mexico. This activity
harms
wildlife, degrades watersheds, pollutes drinking water,
destroys
riparian habitat, and denudes sensitive arid
grasslands and means yearly
financial losses for every
American taxpayer.
The report empowers the
public to know the details of the
elaborate support system our states and
nation provide to
the ranching industry. This information offers a
historical
lesson in the effects of political power when it
proceeds
unchecked by citizen control. It also inspires us to take
action
in manageable steps: each unfair program that is
revised through public
action means a healthier economy and
a healthier ecosystem.
The report
is available on our web site.
http://www.sw-center.org/swcbd/grazing/taxguide.html
_____________________
LAWSUIT
FILED TO SAVE RARE HAWAIIAN SPECIES
The Center for Biological Diversity
filed suit in federal
district court on 8/31 in Honolulu, Hawaii, against
the
United States Fish and Wildlife Service, to secure
protection for four
rare Hawaiian species under the federal
Endangered Species Act (ESA). The
Blackburn's sphinx moth,
Newcomb's snail, Kaua`i cave wolf spider, and Kaua`i
cave
amphipod are found only in the Hawaiian Islands. Despite the
ESA's
non-discretionary deadlines for adding species to the
endangered species
list, the Service is long overdue in
listing these species.
All four
species have been impacted by habitat degradation
and introduced species. For
example, the Newcomb's snail is
a freshwater species that exists in only five
streams on
Kaua`i, with approximately ninety percent of the
surviving
snails concentrated in two populations. The Blackburn's
sphinx
moth was believed to be extinct until it was
rediscovered on Maui in 1984.
The sphinx moth is Hawai`i's
largest native insect, with a wingspan of up to
5 inches.
Unfortunately, the single remaining population identified
in
the proposed listing rule includes an area used by the
Hawai`i National
Guard for military training.
The Center is represented by attorneys David
Henkin and
Kapua Sproat of the Earthjustice Legal Defense Fund
in
Honolulu, Hawaii.
_____________________
CENTER TO SUE TO PROTECT
WHITE ABALONE-SPECIES HAS DECLINED
BY 99.9% IN THIRTY YEARS
The Center
for Biological Diversity formally notified the
National Marine Fisheries
Service (NMFS) on September 2,
1999 of its intent to sue for the agency's
failure to take
action to protect the critically imperiled white
abalone.
The Center filed an emergency petition in April to list
the
species as endangered under the ESA. The ESA requires NMFS
to respond
to the petition within 90 days. NMFS has yet to
respond.
The White
abalone occurs from near Point Conception (near
Santa Barbara, CA) to Punta
Eugenia, Baja California,
Mexico. It lives at a depth of 80-100 feet, feeds
on marine
algae and can live up to 40 years. Within the lifetime of
single
abalone, the entire species has been decimated by
overfishing. It has
declined from between two to four
million individuals in the 1960s, to
between 600 and 1,600
individuals today. Five years ago agency
scientists
predicted the species would be extinct within a decade if
no
action was taken. To date, NMFS has done nothing.
The white abalone
is one of over a dozen California marine
species the Center has identified as
warranting protection
under the ESA.
_____________________
MEXICAN
WOLF REINTRODUCTION UPDATE
A celebration welcoming the Mexican gray wolf
back to the
wilds of Arizona was held in Tucson this last weekend.
Twenty
two of the endangered wolves are roaming the
wildlands of eastern Arizona and
public support is
enthusiastic. The festivities included a film
series
featuring "Death of a Legend" and "Never Cry Wolf," talks
with wolf
experts, poetry by Michael Blake - the author of
"Dances With Wolves" -
mask-making booths and, naturally, a
howling contest for kids.
Since
the first release in Arizona, in January 1998, eleven
wolves have died. Five
of the first 11 released into the
Apache National Forest died of gunshot
wounds. Two are
missing and presumed dead. One died after it was struck by
a
car, a pup was found dead in a holding pen earlier last
week, and two
more pups were found dead Monday.
The first pup's body was shipped to the
National Wildlife
Health Center in Madison, Wis., for a diagnostic necropsy,
a
procedure similar to an autopsy. The pup was found to have
parvovirus a
highly contagious and deadly disease that can
infect domestic and wild
canines. They believe the other two
dead pups may also have contracted
parvo.
Earlier last month the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
captured
the Pipestem Pack because the pack may have killed
two cows on the
Apache-Sitgreaves National Forest. The pack
has been relocated to the
Sevilleta National Wildlife Refuge
south of Albuquerque, N.M. where the two
relocated pups died
on Monday.
_____________________
CENTER WINS
FIRST ROUND IN SAN DIEGO SPECIES PLAN LAWSUIT
A Judge in the Center's
lawsuit against the City of San
Diego's Multiple Species Conservation Program
(MSCP) has
dealt a major setback to developers by ruling against
their
request to intervene in the case. Several development
heavies,
including Pardee Construction, Building Industry
Legal Defense Foundation,
National Association of
Homebuilders, California Building Industry
Association and
the Building Industry Association of San Diego had
sought
leave by the court to participate in the lawsuit in defense
of the
massive species plan.
Covering roughly 900 square miles, San Diego's MSCP
is one
of the largest Habitat Conservation Plans, or HCPs in the
Country
and has been held up by Secretary of the Interior
Bruce Babbitt as a "model
for the nation." Under this
program, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service has
essentially
transferred Endangered Species Act implementation authority
to
the developer friendly City and County of San Diego while
failing to put in
place habitat acquisition and management
safeguards to ensure recovery of
critically endangered
animals and plants. Thirteen conservation groups joined
the
Center in December of 1998 to sue the Service and the City
over the
many failings of the MSCP.
The Center is represented in this case by
attorneys Neil
Levine of Earthlaw, Tara Mueller of the Environmental
Law
Foundation and Dan Rohlf of the Pacific Environmental
Advocacy
Center.
___________________________________________________________
Shane
Jimerfield
Assistant Director
Center for Biological Diversity
Tel:
520.623.5252, ext
302
Fax: 520.623.9797
PO Box 710, Tucson AZ
85702-0710 http://www.sw-center.org