STATE DENIES PROTECTION FOR IMPERILED OWLS
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE December 4, 2003
Craig Breon (408) 252-3748
Kim Delfino (916) 313-5809
More Information: Burrowing owl website
Sacramento, CA - The California Fish and Game Commission (“Commission”) today rejected protection for the western burrowing owl (Athene cunicularia hypugaea) under the California Endangered Species Act (“CESA”). The conservation organizations that submitted a formal petition in April of 2003 to list the owl as a state endangered or threatened species vowed today to go to court to overturn the Commission’s decision. The Commission voted 4-0 against “candidate” status for the species despite precipitous statewide declines in the last two decades. Burrowing owls continue to decline in 50% of their range and have been completely or nearly eliminated from an additional 22% of their range in California. Had the Commission accepted the petition, the owl would have been designated as a “candidate” species while a year-long status review was conducted by DFG. Candidate species receive the same protection under the CESA as endangered or threatened species.
“The Commission’s decision not to accept the burrowing owl petition was outrageous, and lacked any credible biological or legal basis,” said Jeff Miller, spokesperson for the Center for Biological Diversity. “Despite overwhelming evidence the species is now eliminated or in decline throughout more than two-thirds of its range in California, the Department bowed to political pressure from the building industry and agricultural interests. The state’s failure to meet their legal obligation to protect the owl as a candidate species will land them in court and this decision will be overturned.”
“The Commission dodged the major issue, and that is what constitutes a significant portion of the owl’s range in California,” said Craig Breon, Executive Director of the Santa Clara Valley Audubon Society. “The decision implies that losing the species from all coastal areas, the greater Bay Area, and southwestern California is not significant. Do we have to get down to just a handful of owls remaining outside of the San Joaquin and Imperial Valleys to get the species listed?”
“The Fish and Game Commission appears to have decided to pursue the risky strategy of putting all of their eggs in one basket. Apparently, the Commission thinks it is OK to have 70% of the owl population in less than 3% of the state even when that area is undergoing changes in agriculture and increasing urban development. We don’t believe that such an approach is supported by the plain language of the state ESA,” declared Kim Delfino, California Program Director for Defenders of Wildlife.
After receiving a listing petition, the DFG must evaluate the petition and other available information and make a recommendation to the Commission as to whether or not to accept the petition. A species qualifies for listing under CESA if it is endangered or threatened throughout all, or a significant potion, of its range in California. The October 2003 DFG recommendation to the Commission not to accept the petition failed to address the crucial issue of the owl’s status in a “significant portion” of its range and also contained inaccurate and misstated status information. A species must be designated as a “candidate” is there is sufficient information that listing may be warranted, a threshold far surpassed by the listing petition.
The western burrowing owl is a small ground-nesting bird of prairie and grassland habitats. Burrowing owls in California rely upon burrows dug by ground squirrels for nests, and require suitable habitat consisting of open fields with adequate food supply for foraging, low vegetative cover to allow owls to watch for predators, and roosting sites. Many historical accounts by naturalists reported the species was one of the most common birds in California. Burrowing owls ranged throughout the Central Valley, were found in suitable habitat in coastal areas from Marin County south to the Mexican border, and sparsely inhabited desert areas in northeastern and southeastern California. Owls have been in continuous decline throughout the state since at least the 1940s. Burrowing owls are threatened primarily by habitat loss to urban development and eradication of ground squirrels and other burrowing rodents. The common practice of relocating owls from development sites is accelerating local declines in rapidly urbanizing areas.
Surveys conducted throughout most of California during the early 1990s documented a nearly 60% loss in the number of breeding owl colonies known from the 1980s, and a decline in overall population numbers by 8% per year. It was thought that an estimated 9,450 breeding pairs of owls remained statewide at that time. Of 51 California counties within the range of the species, breeding owls have recently been completely eliminated or nearly extirpated from 15 counties (Napa, Sonoma, Marin, San Francisco, San Mateo, Santa Cruz, Monterey, San Luis Obispo, Santa Barbara, Ventura, Los Angeles, Orange, western San Bernardino, western Riverside, and San Diego Counties) and continue to decline in at least 30 other counties.
While burrowing owl populations are declining in urban areas, densities of owls in some areas of the state have increased with intensive agriculture, such as in the Imperial Valley, southern Central Valley, and the lower Colorado River Valley. Over 71% of California’s breeding owls currently live in the margins of agricultural land in the Imperial Valley, an area that comprises only 2.5% percent of the land area of the state. Owls in the Imperial Valley, which primarily nest in burrows in earthen irrigation channels, are facing threats from conversion of agricultural lands to urban development, plans to line earthen canals with concrete, and ground squirrel eradication programs. Over 15% of the state’s breeding owls reside in the southern Central Valley, an area undergoing explosive human population growth and rapid conversion of agricultural lands to urban development.
Other factors contributing to the decline of owls statewide include
destruction of burrows through disking and grading, impacts of pesticides,
increased predation by non-native or feral species, habitat fragmentation,
other human-caused mortality from vehicle strikes, electrified fences,
collisions with wind turbines, shooting, and vandalism of nesting sites.
Throughout the vast majority of the burrowing owl’s range in California, breeding owls persist in only small, declining populations of birds that are highly susceptible to extirpation. The burrowing owl is in imminent danger of becoming extinct throughout a significant portion of its range in California, and requires immediate protection as an endangered or threatened species.
The western burrowing owl has declined significantly throughout its range in North America and is listed as endangered in Canada and threatened in Mexico. The majority of the mid-western and western states within the owl’s range have listed the species: it is state-listed as endangered in Minnesota and Iowa, threatened in Colorado, and as a state Species of Special Concern in Kansas, Nebraska, Oklahoma, South Dakota, North Dakota, Montana, Idaho, Utah, Washington, Oregon, and California. California supports the largest remaining breeding and wintering populations of the species.
The Center for Biological Diversity is a nonprofit environmental organization dedicated to the protection of native species and their habitats. The Center works to protect and restore natural ecosystems and imperiled species through science, education, policy, and environmental law. The Santa Clara Valley Audubon Society works to maintain, preserve, and protect native animal and plant habitats and to foster a greater public awareness of our environment, with emphasis on birds and their ecosystems, particularly in Santa Clara County and the San Francisco Bay Area. Defenders of Wildlife is a nonprofit organization dedicated to the protection of all native wild animals and plants in their natural communities. Defenders programs encourage protection of entire ecosystems and interconnected habitats while protecting predators that serve as indicator species for ecosystem health. The San Bernardino Valley Audubon Society is a non-profit corporation dedicated to conserving and restoring natural ecosystems, focusing on birds and other wildlife for the benefit of humanity and the earth’s biological diversity. The California State Park Rangers Association is an organization of park professionals dedicated to advancement of the highest principles of public service, established to support and preserve California State Parks for present and future generations. The Tri-County Conservation League, Inc. is a public interest corporation with a membership that promotes the educational, recreational and conservation values of the natural resources of the Santa Ana River and its drainage system in Riverside, San Bernardino, and Orange Counties.